Codex Reader-Visit Audit — Final Message
- 日期：2026-05-15
- 视角：低上下文人类读者 / 独立 audit
- Agent：Codex-CLI 0.130，model 默认，调度命令：
codex exec --sandbox read-only --json --output-last-message /tmp/codex-reader-audit-final.txt - - Skill 选择：
$analyze（见~/.codex/skills/analyze/SKILL.md） - 报告形式说明：read-only sandbox 拒绝 shell write 与 apply_patch，因此最终判断以
--output-last-message文件形式返回。本文件即该 final message 的原文，未做任何裁剪。 - Stream log（含 28+ 工具调用 trace，约 320KB）：本仓库不归档；如需复现可重跑命令。
Codex Final Message (verbatim)
I completed the read-only audit, but could not save /tmp/labs-fintecai-codex-reader-audit.md. The environment is read-only: shell write returned operation not permitted, and apply_patch was also rejected by the sandbox. The target file does not exist.
Net judgment: Partial. The entry layer is much clearer: README, CONTEXT-MAP, ACCESS_GUIDE, INDEX, and FinClaw README now have mostly distinct roles. The remaining blockers are mixed entry signals, inconsistent document-class taxonomy, raw process metadata in reader-facing files, and missing concrete V1 artifacts.
Highest-value findings:
| FR | Severity | Citation | Finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| FR-001 | P1 | README.md:23-30, CONTEXT-MAP.md:19-21, registry/project-registry.md:44-48 | First-time route vs strategy route vs registry entry still conflict. |
| FR-002 | P2 | README.md:19-30, CONTEXT-MAP.md:13-26, ACCESS_GUIDE.md:12-23, INDEX.md:18-30 | Entry docs are now mostly role-separated. |
| FR-003 | P1 | INDEX.md:20-30, registry/project-registry.md:54-63 | Taxonomy differs: reference/sync/recovery/tooling vs open-gap/controller-state. |
| FR-011 | P1 | projects/finclaw/strategic-whitepaper.md:15-21, product-definition.md:19-20 | Update/process history appears before product narrative. |
| FR-012 | P2 | README.md:23-30, projects/finclaw/README.md:18-25 | Human reading paths exist, but need stop conditions. |
| FR-015 | P2 | projects/finclaw/mvp-product-definition.md:42-59 | MVP is much more concrete on user, market, scope, and non-goals. |
| FR-015 | P1 | baseline/03-current-baseline.md:142-158, projects/finclaw/mvp-product-definition.md:498-585 | MVP lacks explicit time box, trial size, and kill criteria table. |
| FR-017 | P0 | projects/finclaw/design/v1/v1-prd.md:14-15, v1-design-kickoff-packet.md:288-307 | User Journey, Schema, UI/UX, Agent Orchestration, Evaluation, Trial Ops are explicitly incomplete. |
| FR-017 | P1 | mvp-product-definition.md:105-179, product-object-and-advisor-design.md:81-102 | Fields exist, but no inline JSON examples. |
| FR-017 | P1 | product-object-and-advisor-design.md:30-40, v1-prd.md:255-287 | Lifecycle and UI states exist, but no wireframe or full user journey in the requested path. |
Top R3 fixes: align entry paths, add readiness labels to FinClaw V1 docs, add JSON examples, add a V1 trial decision card, and move provenance/update-history out of first-screen reader surfaces.